Cookies 🍪

Ce site utilise des cookies nécessitant votre consentement.

Aller au contenu
1793781842335.jpeg

Report on CEPANI40 conference: Privilege in Arbitration, from Legal Advice to AI

On 29 October, Lydian hosted a CEPANI40 conference dedicated to legal privilege in arbitration. The discussion focused on some of the key challenges surrounding privilege in arbitral proceedings.

The panel brought together three speakers offering complementary perspectives: Beatrice Van Tornout, Counsel at Fieldfisher; Sofie Vandervaeren, Head of Global Legal Services at Solvay; and Dirk Knottenbelt, independent arbitrator and mediator at ReulingSchutte. The conference was moderated by Marijn De Ruysscher, Counsel at Lydian.

Antoine Uyttebrock
Associate, Lydian.
Antoine Uyttebrock
Associate, Lydian

On 29 October, Lydian hosted a CEPANI40 conference dedicated to legal privilege in arbitration. The discussion focused on some of the key challenges surrounding privilege in arbitral proceedings.

The panel brought together three speakers offering complementary perspectives: Beatrice Van Tornout, Counsel at Fieldfisher; Sofie Vandervaeren, Head of Global Legal Services at Solvay; and Dirk Knottenbelt, independent arbitrator and mediator at ReulingSchutte. The conference was moderated by Marijn De Ruysscher, Counsel at Lydian.

The discussion was structured around three practical scenarios, each addressing a different aspect of legal privilege in arbitration.

1. When is in-house legal advice privileged?

The first scenario concerned a Belgian company that, after obtaining legal advice from its General Counsel, terminated a contract with its US business partner. The US partner subsequently initiated CEPANI arbitration proceedings in Brussels, alleging wrongful termination, and requested the production of all internal communications relating to the termination, including the General Counsel’s advice.

The question was then put to the audience: should the tribunal order disclosure of the General Counsel’s advice?

The discussion highlighted a recurring challenge in international arbitration: different legal systems do not necessarily afford the same level of protection against the disclosure of communications with in-house counsel.

The panel then considered whether involving external counsel could provide greater protection. While this may strengthen a claim to privilege under certain rules, the involvement of external counsel is not sufficient in itself. Using a lawyer merely as a “mailbox”, or routinely copying counsel on ordinary business emails, does not automatically transform the underlying communication into privileged legal advice.

The scenario then took a more contemporary turn: what if the advice had instead been communicated via WhatsApp? Beyond the question of whether such communications may be privileged, instant messaging can encourage exchanges that are informal, immediate and often less carefully considered than traditional written legal advice. Caution is therefore required when legal advice is communicated through such channels.

2. Whose privilege rules should apply?

The second scenario involved a Belgian company and a Singaporean company in CEPANI arbitration proceedings arising from the termination of their joint venture. One party sought to rely on an email from the other side marked “Without Prejudice – Settlement Offer”.

Which standard should the tribunal apply to determine whether the communication may be used as evidence: the most protective standard available to the parties, the least protective standard, or an autonomous international standard? The audience voted predominantly in favour of the third option.

The scenario also raised a practical dilemma: even if a privilege objection ultimately succeeds, has the damage already been done once the tribunal has seen the document? An arbitral tribunal may exclude a document from the evidentiary record, but the arbitrators cannot simply erase from their minds what they have already read.

Against this background, the panel discussed the use of so-called “guerrilla tactics” in arbitration, while recalling that counsel remain bound by their professional and ethical obligations. Where opposing counsel has improperly produced a potentially privileged document, strongly objecting to its production may not always be the most effective strategy, as drawing too much attention to the document may only increase the tribunal’s curiosity. Depending on the circumstances, restraint may therefore prove more effective.

3. What happens to privilege when legal advice is uploaded to AI?

The final scenario concerned a Belgian company facing potential arbitration, which had received advice from external counsel on the weaknesses of its case, its prospects of success and the strategy to adopt. The General Counsel forwarded the advice to the CEO, who uploaded it to a professional AI tool to obtain a summary, although the confidentiality safeguards surrounding the tool remained uncertain. During the subsequent arbitration, the opposing party argued that the upload had compromised the privileged nature of the advice.

The central question was therefore: could uploading privileged legal advice to an AI tool amount to a waiver of privilege?

The discussion began with a practical but important observation: legal advice should be sufficiently clear and accessible for senior management to understand it. If the CEO needs an AI tool to understand it, counsel may need to reconsider how the advice is drafted.

As for the legal consequences of the upload itself, much will depend on the applicable privilege rules. The panel also explored the distinction between the original legal advice and the output generated by the AI tool. Where the tool merely summarises privileged advice without generating any new substantive analysis, the resulting summary may remain protected to the extent that it reflects the underlying privileged content.

Closing reflections

The three scenarios were followed by a Q&A session, during which members of the audience shared their own experiences with privilege issues in arbitration. These exchanges reinforced the evening’s central theme: although privilege is a familiar concept, its application in international arbitration is rarely straightforward, particularly where different legal traditions, new forms of communication and emerging technologies intersect.

The evening concluded with drinks and a walking dinner, giving attendees the opportunity to continue the discussion informally with the speakers.

Contacter LE CEPANI

Rue des Sols 8 — B-1000 Bruxelles
info@cepani.be — +32 2 515 08 35
TVA BE 0413 975 115

Informations financières

BNP  BE45 2100 0760 8589 (BIC GEBABEBB)
KBC  BE28 4300 1693 9120 (BIC KREDBEBB)
ING   BE36 3100 7204 1481 (BIC BBRUBEBB)

Abonnez-vous Ă  notre newsletter

s'abonner

FEB/VBO, Rue Ravenstein 4 — B-1000 Bruxelles
Lun – Ven 09:00h – 12:30h & 14:00h – 17:00h